Greater Montreal's Italian dining scene pulses with authentic flavors that transport you straight to the boot-shaped peninsula. From hand-pulled pasta in cozy trattorias to wood-fired pizzas in bustling neighborhoods, the region delivers serious Italian soul.
We've scoured review data and local buzz from Blainville to Beloeil, analyzing ratings and community feedback to crown the area's most exceptional Italian spots. These aren't just restaurants—they're edible love letters to Italy.
📍 All 10 Locations
⚡ Quick List
- Chez Antonio — Boulevard Comfort Classic
- Osteria Pollino — Authentic Osteria Excellence
- Piazza Salumi — Artisanal Market Magic
- Trattoria Da Gina — Laval Family Favorite
- Le Mista — Beloeil Pizza Paradise
- Il Pagliaccio — Upscale Eggplant Elegance
- Osteria MKT — Market-Fresh Italian Craft
- Restaurant Moccione — Handmade Pasta Perfection
- La Verità — West Island Sophistication
- Taormina Lounge — Lachine Lounge Luxury
1. Chez Antonio
✨ Best for: Boulevard Comfort Classic
📍 Blainville · ⭐ 5.0 · $
Chez Antonio brings old-school Italian comfort to Blainville's busy boulevard scene with their legendary mushroom soup that locals swear rivals nonna's recipe. The steak hamburger gets an Italian twist that somehow works perfectly, while their crispy golden fries provide the ideal comfort food finale. Blue-collar workers and families pack this unpretentious spot where hearty portions and honest flavors matter more than fancy presentations.
Must-Order:
Mushroom SoupSteak HamburgerFries
Insider Tip: Free street parking fills up quickly during dinner rush, so arrive by 5:30 PM to snag a convenient boulevard spot.
2. Osteria Pollino
✨ Best for: Authentic Osteria Excellence
📍 Montreal · ⭐ 5.0 · $
Osteria Pollino captures the essence of Southern Italy's rustic dining culture right in Montreal's heart. The chef's daily recommendations showcase seasonal ingredients prepared with techniques passed down through generations, creating dishes that change with the market's best offerings. Expect robust flavors, generous wine pours, and the kind of warmth that makes strangers feel like family around every shared table.
Must-Order:
Chef's RecommendationHouse SpecialtySeasonal Pasta
Insider Tip: Call ahead during peak hours as this intimate osteria fills up fast with regulars who know quality when they taste it.
3. Piazza Salumi
✨ Best for: Artisanal Market Magic
📍 Montreal · ⭐ 5.0 · $
Piazza Salumi transforms Italian market culture into an immersive dining experience where Fumagalli cold cuts steal every show. Their artisanal cheese selection spans Italy's diverse regions, perfectly paired with freshly baked breads that arrive warm and fragrant. Food enthusiasts and cheese lovers crowd the cozy seating area, savoring combinations that showcase Italy's incredible charcuterie traditions.
Must-Order:
Fumagalli Cold CutsArtisanal CheesesFreshly Baked Breads
Insider Tip: The cozy seating area gets packed during lunch rush, so arrive before 11:30 AM for the most relaxed market dining experience.
4. Trattoria Da Gina
✨ Best for: Laval Family Favorite
📍 Laval · ⭐ 4.8 · $
Trattoria Da Gina serves Laval families the kind of Italian comfort food that keeps multiple generations coming back weekly. Their chicken preparations showcase Mediterranean herbs and cooking techniques that elevate simple ingredients into memorable meals. The pizza arrives with perfectly charred crusts and generous toppings that satisfy both traditionalists and adventurous eaters seeking authentic Italian flavors.
Must-Order:
Chicken SpecialPizza MargheritaCaesar Salad
Insider Tip: This Laval favorite fills up quickly on weekends, so calling ahead ensures you won't wait for their famous Italian comfort food.
5. Le Mista
✨ Best for: Beloeil Pizza Paradise
📍 Beloeil · ⭐ 4.7 · $
Le Mista has become Beloeil's go-to destination for Italian classics executed with precision and passion. Their pizza dough ferments slowly for complex flavors while pasta dishes showcase al dente perfection that Italian purists demand. Local couples and friend groups appreciate the relaxed atmosphere where conversation flows as smoothly as the reasonably priced wine selections.
Must-Order:
Quattro Stagioni PizzaPasta CarbonaraTiramisu
Insider Tip: Street parking can be tricky during peak hours, but the nearby residential streets offer plenty of convenient spots within easy walking distance.
6. Il Pagliaccio
✨ Best for: Upscale Eggplant Elegance
Tripadvisor📍 Montreal · ⭐ 4.6 · $$$$
Il Pagliaccio elevates Italian dining to fine art with their signature eggplant parmigiana that melts like silk against perfectly balanced tomato sauce. The beet salad provides unexpected earthiness while the chocolate lava cake delivers molten decadence that caps off sophisticated meals. Montreal's food scene regulars treat this upscale spot as their special occasion Italian destination.
Must-Order:
Eggplant ParmigianaBeet SaladChocolate Lava Cake
Insider Tip: Weekend reservations are essential at this upscale spot where Montreal's food lovers gather for special Italian dining experiences.
7. Osteria MKT
✨ Best for: Market-Fresh Italian Craft
Tripadvisor📍 Montreal · ⭐ 4.6 · $$$$
Osteria MKT showcases market-driven Italian cuisine where daily specials reflect the chef's creative interpretations of seasonal ingredients. House specialties change regularly, ensuring repeat visitors always discover new flavor combinations rooted in Italian tradition. The kitchen's commitment to fresh, local sourcing creates dishes that capture both Italian soul and Montreal's vibrant food culture.
Must-Order:
Chef's RecommendationHouse SpecialtySeasonal Risotto
Insider Tip: Peak dining hours require advance reservations as this market-fresh Italian spot draws serious food enthusiasts who plan ahead.
8. Restaurant Moccione
✨ Best for: Handmade Pasta Perfection
📍 Montreal · ⭐ 4.6 · $
Restaurant Moccione crafts handmade pasta with the kind of attention that makes Italian grandmothers weep with joy. Their osso buco falls off the bone while the tiramisu provides clouds of mascarpone heaven that locals consider Montreal's finest. Food lovers squeeze into the intimate dining room where every dish showcases traditional techniques executed with modern precision.
Must-Order:
Handmade PastaOsso BucoTiramisu
Insider Tip: The intimate dining room has limited seating, so early arrival secures the best tables for their exceptional handmade pasta experience.
9. La Verità
✨ Best for: West Island Sophistication
📍 Dollard-des-Ormeaux · ⭐ 4.5 · $$$
La Verità brings West Island sophistication to Italian dining with perfectly grilled steaks that showcase Mediterranean seasonings and techniques. Their homemade pasta varies daily, reflecting the chef's commitment to fresh preparations that honor Italian traditions. Dollard-des-Ormeaux residents consider this their neighborhood's crown jewel where special celebrations deserve memorable Italian flavors.
Must-Order:
Grilled SteakHomemade PastaPanna Cotta
Insider Tip: Weekend evenings get lively fast, so arriving early guarantees a table in the energetic atmosphere that locals love.
10. Taormina Lounge
✨ Best for: Lachine Lounge Luxury
📍 Lachine · ⭐ 4.5 · $$$
Taormina Lounge transforms Lachine dining with crispy calamari that achieves the perfect balance between tender interior and golden exterior crunch. Their pasta dishes showcase bold flavors and generous portions that satisfy both comfort food cravings and sophisticated palates. The charming patio becomes summer's hottest Italian dining destination where people-watching enhances every memorable meal.
Must-Order:
Crispy CalamariSeafood LinguineCannoli
Insider Tip: The charming patio offers the best people-watching experience, but weekend spots fill up quickly so arrive early for prime seating.
Tips for Finding Great Italian Food in Greater Montreal
Timing is Everything: Most authentic Italian spots in Greater Montreal get packed during traditional dinner hours. Arrive early or make reservations to avoid disappointment at the most popular locations.
Follow the Pasta: Look for restaurants making fresh pasta daily—it's often the best indicator of serious Italian cooking. Ask your server about daily specials featuring house-made varieties.
Venture Beyond Montreal: Some of Greater Montreal's best Italian gems hide in suburbs like Laval, Beloeil, and Dollard-des-Ormeaux where rents allow for bigger portions and family-friendly pricing.
Market-Fresh Matters: The best Italian restaurants change their menus based on seasonal ingredients. Ask about daily specials that showcase what's fresh from local markets.
Frequently Asked Questions
How We Picked These Spots
We analyzed ratings, local feedback, and dining consistency across Greater Montreal's Italian restaurant scene to identify standout performers. Our selections balance authentic cuisine quality, value, and the kind of repeat customer loyalty that defines truly exceptional neighborhood Italian dining.
Every restaurant on this list has a full profile on our site with photos, hours, menus, and insider tips.
Last updated: February 2026
